Shopping on line can be easy, simple and save you lots of money. It can also take a lot of your time, frustrate you, and result in unwanted purchases. Now the same can be said for regular high street shopping, but with the vast opportunity presented by the Internet it will pay you to spend a few minutes reading this and understanding how to better optimize your Counterpoint shopping experience:
1. Compare - without doubt the biggest advantage that the Counterpoint offers shoppers today is the ability to compare thousands of Counterpoint at a time. This is a great thing, but not necessarily all the time! Too much can be daunting at times so take advantage of the great comparison sites and where possible let them do the hard work for you.
2. Research - if it has been said it will be on the internet. Ignorance is no longer a justifiable reason for buying the wrong thing. Take the time to research in detail everything that you could possible want to know about
3. Testimonials - don't know anybody that has bought a Counterpoint? Wrong! If the Counterpoint is good the internet will let you know. Use the Internet as a friend and get testimonials before you buy.
4. Questions - Got a question about Counterpoint then search the Forums, FAQ's, Blogs etc. Don't be afraid to ask .....
5. Reputation - Never heard of the company selling Counterpoint? Don't worry, no reason why you should know every company in the world, but you know someone that does! Use the internet to find out what people are saying about Counterpoint and build up a picture of their reputation for sales, returns, customer service, delivery etc.
6. Returns - still worried that even after all of the above your Counterpoint wont be what you want? Check out the returns policy. There is so much competition now that someone, somewhere is bound to offer the terms that you are comfortable with.
7. Feedback - happy with your Counterpoint then let people know, after all you are depending on others people input in your buying decision, so why not give a little back.
8. Security - check for the yellow padlock on the Counterpoint site before you buy, and the s after http:/ /i.e. https:// = a secure site
9. Contact - got a question about Counterpoint, or want to leave a comment then check out the sites contact page. Reputable companies have them and respond.
10. Payment - ready to pay for your Counterpoint, then use your credit card or PayPal! Be aware of companies that don't accept them, there may be genuine reasons but given the huge amount of choice you have when buying online there is no reason at all not to buy via credit card or PayPal.
In
music,
counterpoint is the relationship between two or more Register (music) that are independent in contour and rhythm, and interdependent in harmony. It has most commonly been identified in Western music, developing strongly in the renaissance music, and also dominant in much of the common practice period, especially in Baroque music. The term comes from the Latin
punctum contra punctum ("note against note"). The adjectival form
contrapuntal shows this Latin source more transparently.
General principles
In all eras, writing of music organized contrapuntally has been subject to rules, sometimes strict. By definition, Chord (music) occur when multiple notes sound simultaneously; however, chordal, harmonic, "
vertical (music)" features are considered secondary and almost incidental when counterpoint is the predominant textural element. Counterpoint focuses on melodic interaction rather than harmonic effects generated when melodic strands sound together. In the words of John Rahn:
"It is hard to write a beautiful song. It is harder to write several individually beautiful songs that, when sung simultaneously, sound as a more beautiful polyphonic whole. The internal structures that create each of the voices separately must contribute to the emergent structure of the polyphony, which in turn must reinforce and comment on the structures of the individual voices. The way that is accomplished in detail is...'counterpoint'." Rahn, John (2000).
Music Inside Out: Going Too Far in Musical Essays, p. 177. ISBN 90-5701-332-0.
The separation of harmony and counterpoint is not absolute. It is impossible to write simultaneous lines without producing harmony, and impossible to write harmony without linear activity. The composer who chooses to ignore one aspect in favour of the other still must face the fact that the listener cannot simply turn off harmonic or linear hearing at will; thus the composer risks creating annoying distractions unintendedly.
Johann Sebastian Bach's counterpoint—often considered the most profound synthesis of the two dimensions ever achieved—is extremely rich harmonically and always clearly directed tonally, while the individual lines remain fascinating.
Development
Counterpoint was elaborated extensively in the
Renaissance music period, but composers of the Baroque music period brought counterpoint to a kind of culmination, and it may be said that, broadly speaking, harmony then took over as the predominant organizing principle in musical composition. The Baroque composer
Johann Sebastian Bach wrote most of his music incorporating counterpoint, and explicitly and systematically explored the full range of contrapuntal possibilities in such works as The Art of Fugue.
Given the way terminology in music history has evolved, such music created from the Baroque music period on is described as contrapuntal, while music from before Baroque times is called
polyphony. Hence, the earlier composer
Josquin des Prez is said to have written polyphonic music.
Homophony, by contrast with polyphony, features music in which
chord (music) or vertical interval (music) work with a single melody without much consideration of the melodic character of the added
accompanying elements, or of their melodic interactions with the melody they accompany. As suggested above, most popular music written today is predominantly homophonic, its composition governed mainly by considerations of chord and harmony; but, while general tendencies can often be fairly strong one way or another, rather than describing a musical work in absolute terms as either polyphonic or homophonic, it is a question of degree.
The form or compositional genre known as fugue is perhaps the most complex contrapuntal convention. Other examples include the
round (music) (familiar in folk traditions) and the
Canon (music).
In musical composition, contrapuntal techniques are important for enabling composers to generate musical
ironies that serve not only to intrigue listeners into listening more intently to the spinning out of complexities found within the
Texture (music) of a polyphonic composition, but also to draw them all the more into hearing the working out of these figures and interactions of musical dialogue. A melodic fragment, heard alone, makes a particular impression; but when the fragment is heard simultaneously with other melodic ideas, or combined in unexpected ways with itself (as in a canon or fugue), greater depths of affective meaning are revealed. Through
Musical development of a musical idea, the fragments undergo a working out into something musically greater than sum of the parts, something conceptually more profound than a single pleasing melody.
Excellent examples of counterpoint in jazz include Gerry Mulligan's
Young Blood,
Bill Holman's
Invention for Guitar and Trumpet and his
Theme and Variations, as well as recordings by
Stan Getz,
Bob Brookmeyer, Johnny Richards, and Jimmy Giuffre. Corozine, Vince (2002).
Arranging Music for the Real World: Classical and Commercial Aspects, p. 34. ISBN 0-7866-4961-5.
Species counterpoint
Species counterpoint is a type of so-called
strict counterpoint, developed as a pedagogical tool, in which a student progresses through several "species" of increasing complexity, always working a very plain given part in the cantus firmus (Latin for "fixed melody"). The student gradually attains the ability to write
free counterpoint (that is, less rigorously constrained counterpoint, usually without a cantus firmus) according to the rules at the given time.Jeppeson, Knud.
Counterpoint: the polyphonic vocal style of the sixteenth century, English translation 1939, reprint by Dover, NY, 1992. ISBN 0-486-27036-X. The idea is at least as old as
1532, when Giovanni Lanfranco described a similar concept in his
Scintille di musica. The late 16th century Venetian school theorist
Gioseffe Zarlino elaborated on the idea in his influential
Le institutioni harmoniche, and it was first presented in a codified form in 1619 by
Lodovico Zacconi in his
Prattica di musica. Zacconi, unlike later theorists, included a few extra contrapuntal techniques as species, for example
Inversion (music).
By far the most famous pedagogue to use the term, and the one who made it famous, was Johann Fux. In 1725 he published
Gradus ad Parnassum (
Steps to Parnassus), a work intended to help teach students how to compose, using counterpoint—specifically, the contrapuntal style as practised by Giovanni Pierluigi da Palestrina in the late 16th century—as the principal technique. As the basis for his simplified and often over-restrictive codification of Palestrina's practice (see
General notes, below), Fux described five species:
Note against note;
Two notes against one;
Four (extended by others to include three, or six, etc.) notes against one;
Notes offset against each other (as Nonchord tone);
All the first four species together, as "florid" counterpoint.
A succession of later theorists imitated Fux's seminal work quite closely, but often with some small and idiosyncratic modifications in the rules. A good example is Luigi Cherubini.Cherubini, Luigi,
Cours de contrepoint et de fugue, Paris, 1835
Considerations for all species
Students of species counterpoint usually practice writing counterpoint in all the
musical mode except Locrian mode (Ionian mode, Dorian mode, Phrygian mode,
Lydian mode,
Mixolydian mode and
Aeolian mode). The following rules apply to melodic writing in each species, for each part:
The final must be approached by Steps and skips. If the final is approached from below, the leading tone must be raised, except in the case of the Phrygian mode. Thus, in the Dorian mode on D, a C# is necessary at the cadence.
Permitted melodic intervals are the perfect fourth, fifth, and octave, as well as the major and minor second, major and minor third, and ascending minor sixth. When the ascending minor sixth is used it must be immediately followed by motion downwards.
If writing two Steps and skips in the same direction—something which must be done only rarely—the second must be smaller than the first, and the interval between the first and the third note may not be dissonant.
If writing a skip in one direction, it is best to proceed after the skip with motion in the other direction.
The interval of a tritone in three notes is to be avoided (for example, an ascending melodic motion F - A - B natural), as is the interval of a seventh in three notes.
And, in all species, the following rules apply concerning the combination of the parts:
The counterpoint must begin and end on a perfect Consonance and dissonance.
Contrary motion should predominate.
Perfect consonances must be approached by oblique or contrary motion
Imperfect consonances may be approached by any type of motion
The interval of a tenth should not be exceeded between two adjacent parts, unless by necessity.
Build from the bass, upward.
Finally, in species counterpoint it is important to remember that the interval of the perfect fourth is usually considered a dissonance.
First species
In
first species counterpoint, each note in every added part (parts being also referred to as
lines or
voices) sounds against one note in the cantus firmus. Notes in all parts are sounded simultaneously, and move against each other simultaneously. The species is said to be
expanded if any of the added notes are broken up (simply repeated).
In the present context, a "step" is a melodic interval of a half or whole step. A "skip" is an interval of a third or fourth. (See
Steps and skips.) An interval of a fifth or larger is referred to as a "leap".
A few further rules given by Fux, by study of the Palestrina style, and usually given in the works of later counterpoint pedagogues, are as follows. Some are vague, and since good judgement and taste have been regarded by contrapuntists as more important than strict observance of mechanical rules, there are many more cautions than prohibitions. But some are closer to being mandatory, and are accepted by most authorities.
Begin and end on either the unison, octave, or fifth, unless the added part is underneath, in which case begin and end only on unison or octave.
Use no unisons except at the beginning or end.
Avoid Consecutive fifths between any two parts; and avoid Consecutive fifths#Hidden consecutives: that is, movement by Contrary motion to a perfect fifth or octave, unless one part (sometimes restricted to the higher of the parts) moves by step.
Avoid moving in parallel fourths. (In practice Palestrina and others frequently allowed themselves such progressions, especially if they do not involve the lowest of the parts.)
Avoid moving in parallel thirds or sixths for very long.
Attempt to keep any two adjacent parts within a tenth of each other, unless an exceptionally pleasing line can be written by moving outside of that range.
Avoid having any two parts move in the same direction by skip.
Attempt to have as much contrary motion as possible.
Avoid dissonant intervals between any two parts: major or minor 2nd, major or minor 7th, any augmented or diminished interval, and perfect fourth (in many contexts).
In the following example in two parts, the cantus firmus is the lower part. (The same cantus firmus is used for later examples also. Each is in the Dorian mode.)
Second species
In
second species counterpoint, two notes in each of the added parts work against each longer note in the given part. The species is said to be
expanded if one of these two shorter notes differs in length from the other.
Additional considerations in second species counterpoint are as follows, and are in addition to the considerations for first species:
It is permissible to begin on an upbeat, leaving a half-rest in the added voice.
The accented beat must have only consonance (perfect or imperfect). The unaccented beat may have dissonance, but only as a passing tone, i.e. it must be approached and left by step in the same direction.
Avoid the interval of the unison except at the beginning or end of the example, except that it may occur on the unaccented portion of the bar.
Use caution with successive accented perfect fifths or octaves. They must not be used as part of a sequential pattern.
Third species
In
third species counterpoint, four (or three, etc.) notes move against each longer note in the given part. As with second species, it is called
expanded if the shorter notes vary in length among themselves.
Fourth species
In
fourth species counterpoint, some notes are sustained or
suspended in an added part while notes move against them in the given part, often creating a
Consonance and dissonance on the beat, followed by the suspended note then changing (and "catching up") to create a subsequent Consonance and dissonance with the note in the given part as it continues to sound. As before, fourth species counterpoint is said to be
expanded when the added-part notes vary in length among themselves. The technique requires chains of notes sustained across the boundaries determined by beat, and so creates syncopation.
Florid counterpoint
In
fifth species counterpoint, sometimes called
florid counterpoint, the other four species of counterpoint are combined within the added parts. In the example, the first and second bars are second species, the third bar is third species, and the fourth and fifth bars are third and embellished fourth species.
General notes
It is a common and pedantic misconception that counterpoint is
defined by these five species, and therefore anything that does not follow the strict rules of the five species is not "proper" counterpoint. This is not true; although much contrapuntal music of the
common practice period adheres to the spirit of the rules, and often to the letter of them, the exceptions are many. Fux's book and its concept of "species" was purely a method of teaching counterpoint, not a definitive or rigidly prescriptive set of rules for it. He arrived at his method of teaching (or so he believed, at least) by examining the works of
Giovanni Pierluigi da Palestrina, an important late 16th-century composer who in Fux's time was held in the highest esteem as a contrapuntist. Works in the contrapuntal style of the 16th century—the "prima pratica" or "
stile antico," as it was called by later composers—were often said by Fux's contemporaries to be in "Palestrina style." Indeed, Fux's treatise is a compendium of Palestrina's actual techniques, simplified and regularised for pedagogical use (and so permitting fewer liberties than occurred in actual practice).
Contrapuntal derivations
Since the Renaissance music period in European music, much music which is considered contrapuntal has been written in imitative counterpoint. In imitative counterpoint, two or more voices enter at different times, and (especially when entering) each voice repeats some version of the same melodic element. The
fantasia (music), the
ricercar, and later, the
Canon (music) and
fugue (the contrapuntal form
par excellence) all feature imitative counterpoint, which also frequently appears in choir works such as
motets and
madrigal (music). Imitative counterpoint has spawned a number of devices that composers have turned to in order to give their works both
mathematical rigor and expressive range. Some of these devices include:
- Inversion (music)#Inverted melodies: The inverse of a given fragment of melody is the fragment turned upside down—so if the original fragment has a rising major third (see interval (music)), the inverted fragment has a falling major (or perhaps minor) third, etc. (Compare, in twelve tone technique, the inversion of the tone row, which is the so-called prime series turned upside down.) (Note: in invertible counterpoint, including double and triple counterpoint, the term inversion is used in a different sense altogether. At least one pair of parts is switched, so that the one that was higher becomes lower. See Inversion (music)#Inversion in counterpoint; it is not a kind of imitation, but a rearrangement of the parts.)
- Permutation (music) refers to the contrapuntal device whereby notes in an imitative voice sound backwards in relation to their order in the original.
- Retrograde inversion is where the imitative voice sounds notes both backwards and upside down.
- Augmentation (music) is when in one of the parts in imitative counterpoint the notes are extended in duration compared to the rate at which they were sounded when introduced.
- Diminution is when in one of the parts in imitative counterpoint the notes are reduced in duration compared to the rate at which they were sounded when introduced.
Dissonant counterpoint
Dissonant counterpoint was first theorized by
Charles Seeger as "at first purely a school-room discipline," consisting of species counterpoint but with all the traditional rules reversed. First species counterpoint is required to be all dissonances, establishing "dissonance, rather than consonance, as the rule," and consonances are "resolved" through a skip, not step. He wrote that "the effect of this discipline" was "one of purification." Other
aspects of music, such as rhythm, could be "dissonated" by applying the same principle (Charles Seeger, "On Dissonant Counterpoint," Modern Music 7, no. 4 (June-July 1930): 25-26).
Seeger was not the first to employ dissonant counterpoint, but was the first to theorize and promote it. Other composers who have used dissonant counterpoint, if not in the exact manner prescribed by Charles Seeger, include Ruth Crawford-Seeger,
Carl Ruggles, Henry Cowell, Henry Brant, Dane Rudhyar, Lou Harrison, Fartein Valen, and Arnold Schoenberg.
Counterpoint in popular music
- Counterpoint is common in musical theatre, especially in songs that try to compare or contrast two or more characters' views. Stephen Sondheim, for example, is famous for extensive use of counterpoint. In his dark operetta Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street, many songs are written using contrapuntal techniques, most notably 'Kiss Me Quartet'. Other musical theatre composers use it as well: in Les Miserables, for example, the song One Day More (song) features almost the entire main cast singing contrapuntal vocals at the same time. Irving Berlin also wrote counterpoint in American popular music, including on "You're Just in Love" and "Play a Simple Melody". There are also examples of counterpoint in the shows The Music Man (Pick-a-little, Talk-a-little and Goodnight Ladies) and La Cage Aux Folles (Cocktail Counterpoint), which has 7 parts sung first seperately then together.
- Synth pop bands from the 1980s and onwards were especially fertile in use of counterpoint where heavy programming allowed for new textures using intertwining horizontal lines. Composers of this type of counterpoint included Yazoo, Depeche Mode, Erasure and Ultravox.
- Many Beach Boys songs employ, or partly employ, counterpoint. The vocal outro of the song God Only Knows is a famous example.
- Country songs feature counterpoint, such as the 2000 hit single I Hope You Dance (song) by Lee Ann Womack, where the country band Sons of the Desert (band) sing a counterpoint chorus over top of Womack's main chorus.
- During the progressive rock era of the 1970s the counterpoint was not widely used. Some artists tried to use it more or less consciously, however there was only one band, Gentle Giant, for which it was a main composing technique.
In literature
Palestinian-American Post-colonialism critical theory Edward Said, himself a pianist and music critic, wrote extensively about how
literature could be contrapuntal.One of Aldous Huxley's well known novels is Point Counter-point.
See also
Sources
External links
- An Introduction to Species Counterpoint
- ntoll.org: Species Counterpoint by Nicholas H. Tollervey
- Principles of Counterpoint by Alan Belkin
- Orima: The History of Experimental Music in Northern California: On Dissonant Counterpoint by David Nicholls from his American Experimental Music: 1890-1940
- Virginia Tech Multimedia Music Dictionary: Dissonant counterpoint examples and definition
- De-Mystifying Tonal Counterpoint or How to Overcome Your Fear of Composing Counterpoint Exercises by Christopher Dylan Bailey, composer at Columbia University
- Counterpointer:Software tutorial for the study of counterpointby Jeffrey Evans
In
music,
counterpoint is the relationship between two or more Register (music) that are independent in contour and
rhythm, and interdependent in harmony. It has most commonly been identified in
Western music, developing strongly in the renaissance music, and also dominant in much of the
common practice period, especially in
Baroque music. The term comes from the
Latin punctum contra punctum ("note against note"). The adjectival form
contrapuntal shows this Latin source more transparently.
General principles
In all eras, writing of music organized contrapuntally has been subject to rules, sometimes strict. By definition, Chord (music) occur when multiple notes sound simultaneously; however, chordal, harmonic, "vertical (music)" features are considered secondary and almost incidental when counterpoint is the predominant textural element. Counterpoint focuses on melodic interaction rather than harmonic effects generated when melodic strands sound together. In the words of John Rahn:
"It is hard to write a beautiful song. It is harder to write several individually beautiful songs that, when sung simultaneously, sound as a more beautiful polyphonic whole. The internal structures that create each of the voices separately must contribute to the emergent structure of the polyphony, which in turn must reinforce and comment on the structures of the individual voices. The way that is accomplished in detail is...'counterpoint'." Rahn, John (2000).
Music Inside Out: Going Too Far in Musical Essays, p. 177. ISBN 90-5701-332-0.
The separation of harmony and counterpoint is not absolute. It is impossible to write simultaneous lines without producing harmony, and impossible to write harmony without linear activity. The composer who chooses to ignore one aspect in favour of the other still must face the fact that the listener cannot simply turn off harmonic or linear hearing at will; thus the composer risks creating annoying distractions unintendedly.
Johann Sebastian Bach's counterpoint—often considered the most profound synthesis of the two dimensions ever achieved—is extremely rich harmonically and always clearly directed tonally, while the individual lines remain fascinating.
Development
Counterpoint was elaborated extensively in the
Renaissance music period, but composers of the Baroque music period brought counterpoint to a kind of culmination, and it may be said that, broadly speaking,
harmony then took over as the predominant organizing principle in musical composition. The Baroque composer
Johann Sebastian Bach wrote most of his music incorporating counterpoint, and explicitly and systematically explored the full range of contrapuntal possibilities in such works as The Art of Fugue.
Given the way terminology in music history has evolved, such music created from the
Baroque music period on is described as contrapuntal, while music from before Baroque times is called polyphony. Hence, the earlier composer
Josquin des Prez is said to have written polyphonic music.
Homophony, by contrast with polyphony, features music in which
chord (music) or vertical interval (music) work with a single melody without much consideration of the melodic character of the added
accompanying elements, or of their melodic interactions with the melody they accompany. As suggested above, most popular music written today is predominantly homophonic, its composition governed mainly by considerations of chord and harmony; but, while general tendencies can often be fairly strong one way or another, rather than describing a musical work in absolute terms as either polyphonic or homophonic, it is a question of degree.
The form or compositional genre known as fugue is perhaps the most complex contrapuntal convention. Other examples include the
round (music) (familiar in folk traditions) and the Canon (music).
In musical composition, contrapuntal techniques are important for enabling composers to generate musical
ironies that serve not only to intrigue listeners into listening more intently to the spinning out of complexities found within the
Texture (music) of a polyphonic composition, but also to draw them all the more into hearing the working out of these figures and interactions of musical dialogue. A melodic fragment, heard alone, makes a particular impression; but when the fragment is heard simultaneously with other melodic ideas, or combined in unexpected ways with itself (as in a canon or fugue), greater depths of affective meaning are revealed. Through
Musical development of a musical idea, the fragments undergo a working out into something musically greater than sum of the parts, something conceptually more profound than a single pleasing melody.
Excellent examples of counterpoint in jazz include Gerry Mulligan's
Young Blood, Bill Holman's
Invention for Guitar and Trumpet and his
Theme and Variations, as well as recordings by
Stan Getz, Bob Brookmeyer, Johnny Richards, and Jimmy Giuffre. Corozine, Vince (2002).
Arranging Music for the Real World: Classical and Commercial Aspects, p. 34. ISBN 0-7866-4961-5.
Species counterpoint
Species counterpoint is a type of so-called
strict counterpoint, developed as a pedagogical tool, in which a student progresses through several "species" of increasing complexity, always working a very plain given part in the cantus firmus (Latin for "fixed melody"). The student gradually attains the ability to write
free counterpoint (that is, less rigorously constrained counterpoint, usually without a cantus firmus) according to the rules at the given time.Jeppeson, Knud.
Counterpoint: the polyphonic vocal style of the sixteenth century, English translation 1939, reprint by Dover, NY, 1992. ISBN 0-486-27036-X. The idea is at least as old as
1532, when Giovanni Lanfranco described a similar concept in his
Scintille di musica. The late 16th century Venetian school theorist Gioseffe Zarlino elaborated on the idea in his influential
Le institutioni harmoniche, and it was first presented in a codified form in 1619 by
Lodovico Zacconi in his
Prattica di musica. Zacconi, unlike later theorists, included a few extra contrapuntal techniques as species, for example
Inversion (music).
By far the most famous pedagogue to use the term, and the one who made it famous, was
Johann Fux. In 1725 he published
Gradus ad Parnassum (
Steps to Parnassus), a work intended to help teach students how to compose, using counterpoint—specifically, the contrapuntal style as practised by Giovanni Pierluigi da Palestrina in the late 16th century—as the principal technique. As the basis for his simplified and often over-restrictive codification of Palestrina's practice (see
General notes, below), Fux described five species:
Note against note;
Two notes against one;
Four (extended by others to include three, or six, etc.) notes against one;
Notes offset against each other (as Nonchord tone);
All the first four species together, as "florid" counterpoint.
A succession of later theorists imitated Fux's seminal work quite closely, but often with some small and idiosyncratic modifications in the rules. A good example is Luigi Cherubini.Cherubini, Luigi,
Cours de contrepoint et de fugue, Paris, 1835
Considerations for all species
Students of species counterpoint usually practice writing counterpoint in all the musical mode except Locrian mode (
Ionian mode, Dorian mode, Phrygian mode,
Lydian mode, Mixolydian mode and Aeolian mode). The following rules apply to melodic writing in each species, for each part:
The final must be approached by Steps and skips. If the final is approached from below, the leading tone must be raised, except in the case of the Phrygian mode. Thus, in the Dorian mode on D, a C# is necessary at the cadence.
Permitted melodic intervals are the perfect fourth, fifth, and octave, as well as the major and minor second, major and minor third, and ascending minor sixth. When the ascending minor sixth is used it must be immediately followed by motion downwards.
If writing two Steps and skips in the same direction—something which must be done only rarely—the second must be smaller than the first, and the interval between the first and the third note may not be dissonant.
If writing a skip in one direction, it is best to proceed after the skip with motion in the other direction.
The interval of a tritone in three notes is to be avoided (for example, an ascending melodic motion F - A - B natural), as is the interval of a seventh in three notes.
And, in all species, the following rules apply concerning the combination of the parts:
The counterpoint must begin and end on a perfect Consonance and dissonance.
Contrary motion should predominate.
Perfect consonances must be approached by oblique or contrary motion
Imperfect consonances may be approached by any type of motion
The interval of a tenth should not be exceeded between two adjacent parts, unless by necessity.
Build from the bass, upward.
Finally, in species counterpoint it is important to remember that the interval of the perfect fourth is usually considered a dissonance.
First species
In
first species counterpoint, each note in every added part (parts being also referred to as
lines or
voices) sounds against one note in the cantus firmus. Notes in all parts are sounded simultaneously, and move against each other simultaneously. The species is said to be
expanded if any of the added notes are broken up (simply repeated).
In the present context, a "step" is a melodic interval of a half or whole step. A "skip" is an interval of a third or fourth. (See Steps and skips.) An interval of a fifth or larger is referred to as a "leap".
A few further rules given by Fux, by study of the Palestrina style, and usually given in the works of later counterpoint pedagogues, are as follows. Some are vague, and since good judgement and taste have been regarded by contrapuntists as more important than strict observance of mechanical rules, there are many more cautions than prohibitions. But some are closer to being mandatory, and are accepted by most authorities.
Begin and end on either the unison, octave, or fifth, unless the added part is underneath, in which case begin and end only on unison or octave.
Use no unisons except at the beginning or end.
Avoid Consecutive fifths between any two parts; and avoid Consecutive fifths#Hidden consecutives: that is, movement by Contrary motion to a perfect fifth or octave, unless one part (sometimes restricted to the higher of the parts) moves by step.
Avoid moving in parallel fourths. (In practice Palestrina and others frequently allowed themselves such progressions, especially if they do not involve the lowest of the parts.)
Avoid moving in parallel thirds or sixths for very long.
Attempt to keep any two adjacent parts within a tenth of each other, unless an exceptionally pleasing line can be written by moving outside of that range.
Avoid having any two parts move in the same direction by skip.
Attempt to have as much contrary motion as possible.
Avoid dissonant intervals between any two parts: major or minor 2nd, major or minor 7th, any augmented or diminished interval, and perfect fourth (in many contexts).
In the following example in two parts, the cantus firmus is the lower part. (The same cantus firmus is used for later examples also. Each is in the
Dorian mode.)
Second species
In
second species counterpoint, two notes in each of the added parts work against each longer note in the given part. The species is said to be
expanded if one of these two shorter notes differs in length from the other.
Additional considerations in second species counterpoint are as follows, and are in addition to the considerations for first species:
It is permissible to begin on an upbeat, leaving a half-rest in the added voice.
The accented beat must have only consonance (perfect or imperfect). The unaccented beat may have dissonance, but only as a passing tone, i.e. it must be approached and left by step in the same direction.
Avoid the interval of the unison except at the beginning or end of the example, except that it may occur on the unaccented portion of the bar.
Use caution with successive accented perfect fifths or octaves. They must not be used as part of a sequential pattern.
Third species
In
third species counterpoint, four (or three, etc.) notes move against each longer note in the given part. As with second species, it is called
expanded if the shorter notes vary in length among themselves.
Fourth species
In
fourth species counterpoint, some notes are sustained or
suspended in an added part while notes move against them in the given part, often creating a Consonance and dissonance on the beat, followed by the suspended note then changing (and "catching up") to create a subsequent Consonance and dissonance with the note in the given part as it continues to sound. As before, fourth species counterpoint is said to be
expanded when the added-part notes vary in length among themselves. The technique requires chains of notes sustained across the boundaries determined by beat, and so creates
syncopation.
Florid counterpoint
In
fifth species counterpoint, sometimes called
florid counterpoint, the other four species of counterpoint are combined within the added parts. In the example, the first and second bars are second species, the third bar is third species, and the fourth and fifth bars are third and embellished fourth species.
General notes
It is a common and pedantic misconception that counterpoint is
defined by these five species, and therefore anything that does not follow the strict rules of the five species is not "proper" counterpoint. This is not true; although much contrapuntal music of the
common practice period adheres to the spirit of the rules, and often to the letter of them, the exceptions are many. Fux's book and its concept of "species" was purely a method of teaching counterpoint, not a definitive or rigidly prescriptive set of rules for it. He arrived at his method of teaching (or so he believed, at least) by examining the works of Giovanni Pierluigi da Palestrina, an important late 16th-century composer who in Fux's time was held in the highest esteem as a contrapuntist. Works in the contrapuntal style of the 16th century—the "
prima pratica" or "stile antico," as it was called by later composers—were often said by Fux's contemporaries to be in "Palestrina style." Indeed, Fux's treatise is a compendium of Palestrina's actual techniques, simplified and regularised for pedagogical use (and so permitting fewer liberties than occurred in actual practice).
Contrapuntal derivations
Since the Renaissance music period in European music, much music which is considered contrapuntal has been written in imitative counterpoint. In imitative counterpoint, two or more voices enter at different times, and (especially when entering) each voice repeats some version of the same melodic element. The
fantasia (music), the
ricercar, and later, the Canon (music) and fugue (the contrapuntal form
par excellence) all feature imitative counterpoint, which also frequently appears in
choir works such as motets and
madrigal (music). Imitative counterpoint has spawned a number of devices that composers have turned to in order to give their works both
mathematical rigor and expressive range. Some of these devices include:
- Inversion (music)#Inverted melodies: The inverse of a given fragment of melody is the fragment turned upside down—so if the original fragment has a rising major third (see interval (music)), the inverted fragment has a falling major (or perhaps minor) third, etc. (Compare, in twelve tone technique, the inversion of the tone row, which is the so-called prime series turned upside down.) (Note: in invertible counterpoint, including double and triple counterpoint, the term inversion is used in a different sense altogether. At least one pair of parts is switched, so that the one that was higher becomes lower. See Inversion (music)#Inversion in counterpoint; it is not a kind of imitation, but a rearrangement of the parts.)
- Permutation (music) refers to the contrapuntal device whereby notes in an imitative voice sound backwards in relation to their order in the original.
- Retrograde inversion is where the imitative voice sounds notes both backwards and upside down.
- Augmentation (music) is when in one of the parts in imitative counterpoint the notes are extended in duration compared to the rate at which they were sounded when introduced.
- Diminution is when in one of the parts in imitative counterpoint the notes are reduced in duration compared to the rate at which they were sounded when introduced.
Dissonant counterpoint
Dissonant counterpoint was first theorized by
Charles Seeger as "at first purely a school-room discipline," consisting of species counterpoint but with all the traditional rules reversed. First species counterpoint is required to be all dissonances, establishing "dissonance, rather than consonance, as the rule," and consonances are "resolved" through a skip, not step. He wrote that "the effect of this discipline" was "one of purification." Other
aspects of music, such as rhythm, could be "dissonated" by applying the same principle (Charles Seeger, "On Dissonant Counterpoint," Modern Music 7, no. 4 (June-July 1930): 25-26).
Seeger was not the first to employ dissonant counterpoint, but was the first to theorize and promote it. Other composers who have used dissonant counterpoint, if not in the exact manner prescribed by Charles Seeger, include Ruth Crawford-Seeger, Carl Ruggles,
Henry Cowell, Henry Brant, Dane Rudhyar, Lou Harrison,
Fartein Valen, and
Arnold Schoenberg.
Counterpoint in popular music
- Counterpoint is common in musical theatre, especially in songs that try to compare or contrast two or more characters' views. Stephen Sondheim, for example, is famous for extensive use of counterpoint. In his dark operetta Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street, many songs are written using contrapuntal techniques, most notably 'Kiss Me Quartet'. Other musical theatre composers use it as well: in Les Miserables, for example, the song One Day More (song) features almost the entire main cast singing contrapuntal vocals at the same time. Irving Berlin also wrote counterpoint in American popular music, including on "You're Just in Love" and "Play a Simple Melody". There are also examples of counterpoint in the shows The Music Man (Pick-a-little, Talk-a-little and Goodnight Ladies) and La Cage Aux Folles (Cocktail Counterpoint), which has 7 parts sung first seperately then together.
- Synth pop bands from the 1980s and onwards were especially fertile in use of counterpoint where heavy programming allowed for new textures using intertwining horizontal lines. Composers of this type of counterpoint included Yazoo, Depeche Mode, Erasure and Ultravox.
- Many Beach Boys songs employ, or partly employ, counterpoint. The vocal outro of the song God Only Knows is a famous example.
- Country songs feature counterpoint, such as the 2000 hit single I Hope You Dance (song) by Lee Ann Womack, where the country band Sons of the Desert (band) sing a counterpoint chorus over top of Womack's main chorus.
- During the progressive rock era of the 1970s the counterpoint was not widely used. Some artists tried to use it more or less consciously, however there was only one band, Gentle Giant, for which it was a main composing technique.
In literature
Palestinian-American
Post-colonialism critical theory
Edward Said, himself a pianist and music critic, wrote extensively about how
literature could be contrapuntal.One of Aldous Huxley's well known novels is Point Counter-point.
See also
Sources
External links
- An Introduction to Species Counterpoint
- ntoll.org: Species Counterpoint by Nicholas H. Tollervey
- Principles of Counterpoint by Alan Belkin
- Orima: The History of Experimental Music in Northern California: On Dissonant Counterpoint by David Nicholls from his American Experimental Music: 1890-1940
- Virginia Tech Multimedia Music Dictionary: Dissonant counterpoint examples and definition
- De-Mystifying Tonal Counterpoint or How to Overcome Your Fear of Composing Counterpoint Exercises by Christopher Dylan Bailey, composer at Columbia University
- Counterpointer:Software tutorial for the study of counterpointby Jeffrey Evans
Counterpoint-online | Homepage
Launch of Options for Influence; Global campaigns of persuasion in the new worlds of public diplomacy at the RSA, London. On Tuesday 4 March, the British Council launched ...
Counterpoint - Choral music from medieval to modern
Choral music from medieval to modern. Includes programmes, reviews, recordings and photographs.
BBC Radio 4 - Comedy - Counterpoint
The perennially popular music quiz ... You can contact Counterpoint by writing to 'Counterpoint', Room 2121, BBC Manchester, Oxford Road, Manchester, M60 1SJ.
Counterpoint - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
In music, counterpoint is the relationship between two or more voices that are independent in contour and rhythm, and interdependent in harmony.
Counterpoint Arts
Organises concerts, recitals, opera evenings and masterclasses. Dates, information and tickets available. [May not work in all browsers]
CounterPoint Records =-
Drawbar - Leave That Ol' Devil Alone/ Broken & Battered Released: 30 Jun 2008
Five Artists and Counterpoint
images of shoes in limited editions ... Counterpoint was an exhibition of drawings, paintings, prints, paperwork, stained glass, sculpture and textiles at the Saïd Business School ...
Counterpoint Music
Sheet music shop offering syllabus material, repertoire pieces and study books, as well as a range of classical CD-ROMs. Online catalogue and store.
COUNTERPOINT RESEARCH
Counterpoint Research - In Research nothing can be taken for granted...At Counterpoint, we pride ourselves on our track record...
SchenkerGUIDE: Counterpoint
Start page for Schenker's theory of counterpoint ... Introduction Like his theory of harmony, which adapts and draws together a number of older ideas, Schenker's Counterpoint ...